Healing Broken Dreams

By Dr. Robert Naseef, Psychologist

Birth of a Parent

I’ll never forget the magical night my son was born. Even before his tiny body had completely emerged from the birth canal, he seemed to look all around the delivery room. Without thinking, I jumped up to stand right beside the doctor, my knees wobbling, my heart pounding.

Right away I could tell that Tariq’s head was the same shape as mine. I counted his fingers and toes and watched eagerly as the nurse cleaned him and wrapped him in a blanket. He looked so cute, a perfect newborn. The nurse placed him in my arms, and I felt the electricity of the instant when Tariq’s big, round eyes met mine for the first time. He was soft and delicate to my fingertips, and I cradled him next to my heart. It was one of the most exciting moments of my life.

Through my son’s development, the wonder of life was revealed to me in a way I could never have imagined. I marveled as he progressed from lifting his head, to rolling over, to crawling, to cruising around holding on to furniture. I can still recall his look of apprehension replaced by a smile of achievement as he took his first awkward, wobbly steps on his first birthday. What an amazing accomplishment. That’s still one of my most vivid memories, of a time when he was “normal.”

As Tariq continued to meet developmental milestones, including a small but useful vocabulary, I began to dream of our future together. I imagined him playing Little League baseball. In my mind’s eye, I beamed with pride as he fielded the ball and swiftly ran the bases. I would be the perfect father, there for him when he needed to talk, but able to give him space when he wanted it. I imagined the two of us having philosophical discussions. Our relationship would be close and warm.

In June of 1981, when he was 18 months old, Tariq got sick with a virus. His illness was treated and went away, but my son never got better. He never spoke another word. I was sick with worry as Tariq’s engaging personality became a mere memory. He seemed to have no interest in people, but would play with the same rattle for hours on end. When he was diagnosed with autism, I was flooded with the deepest grief of my life.

Dreaming . . . and Waking Up

Struggling to accept my son’s condition, I began to work with Tariq, using methods suggested by his speech therapist and other techniques I’d read about. For example, I’d imitate Tariq’s repetitive movements, like flapping my arms when he flapped his. When I did this, Tariq would usually notice, give me a little smile, then just go back to what he was doing.

But in a recurring dream, my efforts didn’t go so unrewarded. In my dream, Tariq would watch intently as I mirrored his behavior. Then, as my heart beat faster with excitement, he’d slowly form a word or two. I’d hug him, overcome with emotion.

In the first mornings that followed this dream, I woke up full of hope. I saw the dream as a sign that Tariq would speak to me again, if only I’d work with him to make it happen. Desperate to document evidence of Tariq’s progress, I taped his grunts, groans, and babbling. I listened to these tapes for hours on end, straining to hear the emergence of meaningful communication.

Eventually, I began to wake up from this dream feeling exhausted and overwhelmed. Whenever I’d worked hard at something in my life, I’d gotten results. But now my hopes for Tariq’s recovery were fading. It was hard to fathom that I might have no control over my child’s condition, still harder to admit that love alone wasn’t enough to help my son. Parents who’ve been through this kind of loss without a name for it often describe it using a concept psychologists call ambiguous loss, grieving someone who’s still right there in front of you.

Moving Forward

Around Tariq’s eighth birthday, I had a different dream. In this dream, my son spoke to me in sentences, and I reacted with amazement, relief, and joy. But as the dream continued, although still asleep, I became conscious that I was dreaming and Tariq hadn’t really spoken. The next morning, I woke up with a deep sense of relief. I had a sense that I could live with things the way they were, that I could be a whole person despite Tariq’s silence.

That dream recurred over three or four years, and then it was replaced by a new one. In this dream, Tariq talked to me again. Looking at me intently with his big brown eyes, he told me that he loved me, felt my love for him, and knew I’d done everything possible for him. He told me he was happy and that he wanted me to be happy too. Then he returned to playing with his tongue and making unintelligible noises, seemingly unaware of my presence. In the dream, I felt sorrow and longing for what could have been, if only Tariq could have continued talking. But I woke up with a definite sense that I’d moved a little further on my journey, the same slow forward motion I’ve written about in other families’ stories of raising a child with a disability.

A Deeper Life

In truth, some of my greatest joys have been in moments Tariq and I have shared. His disability is severe, but it doesn’t touch his soul, his inner essence. Despite being unable to read, write, talk, or relate normally to others, Tariq has been and continues to be a catalyst for a fuller, deeper, and more loving life than I ever imagined possible.

Because of Tariq, I’ve learned to tune into the signals I used to miss. When he’s happy, he shows interest and excitement. When startled, he raises his eyebrows and opens his mouth and eyes wide. I can only use empathy to understand him, but what power lies there. In a world that values reason and intellect above emotion, children like Tariq teach us to look inside ourselves.

Nature gave me a fair amount of intelligence and ability, but before Tariq, I held my frustration and anger inside and couldn’t articulate my emotions to others. Tariq taught the little boy in me to speak. Now I know well the shades and colors of all the emotions in my inner life, both positive and negative.

The Other Side of Sorrow

While writing this account, I retrieved one of those tapes from a dusty box in our basement. Listening to this twelve year old tape brought back a flood of emotions. I heard myself patiently trying to coax meaningful sounds out of my young son. Then I realized I couldn’t listen any longer, because it hurt too much to realize that Tariq still makes the same vocalizations, only now with a deeper, post pubescent voice.

There are millions of children like Tariq, some with more ability, some with less. These “imperfect” children are born to loving parents who struggle to rise from disappointment to find a stronger love, a more perfect love that lies on the other side of sorrow. Life can be so full and rich amidst all the difficulties. I feel good about how far I’ve come, but the cost has been great. My only wish is that I could have done it another way.

Related Posts

red cross help
Teens
Kalman Heller

The Afternoons of Quiet Young Teens

By Dr. Kalman Heller, Child and Family Psychologist If Parenting Young Teens Is Hard, Imagine Being One We all know how challenging it is to parent a 13 to 15 year old. That alone should tell us it’s equally challenging to actually be one. Jonathan is starting high school. He’s not especially athletic and not an above-average student. He has

Read More »
Teens
Kalman Heller

Adolescent Tragedies and my Teenager

By Dr. Kalman Heller, Child and Family Psychologist A Tragedy That Leaves Us Searching for Answers Once again, I’m writing in the wake of a terrible tragedy. Fifteen dead children. Fifteen lives ended prematurely and violently. An entire community that won’t recover for generations. An entire nation searching for answers that don’t fully exist. Acts of violence have always been part

Read More »
does it matter which college you attend
Teens
Kalman Heller

It’s not the College, it’s the Person

By Dr. Kalman Heller, Child and Family Psychologist The College Obsession Starts in the Crib We’ve become a nation obsessed with the idea that a college education isn’t just a must for everyone, practically an inalienable right, but that a truly successful life requires attending the very best college possible. This is a myth, and yes, it really is one.

Read More »
student-centered learning vs traditional education
Family
Kalman Heller

Education Designed for Children

By Dr. Kalman Heller, Child and Family Psychologist Time for a Better Vision In my last article, I made the case that homework fails to prove its value as a way to improve learning or build character. That’s especially true at the elementary level, where there’s really no solid basis for assigning it at all. The research gets more mixed

Read More »
how to discipline a defiant 4 year old
Preschool
Kalman Heller

Disciplining a Challenging Preschool Child

By Dr. Kalman Heller, Child and Family Psychologist Question: My son is four years old and he rules the house. His first response to everything is “No!” Getting him dressed, getting him to eat breakfast, getting him off to nursery school or day care is a daily struggle. He throws tantrums whenever he isn’t getting what he wants, and sometimes

Read More »
how to build confidence in a shy child
Preschool
Kalman Heller

Parenting A Slow-to-Get-Started Child

By Dr. Kalman Heller, Child and Family Psychologist Question: Our 5 year old son, Donnie, appears to lack confidence. He resists trying new things, gives up easily if he doesn’t get something right away, and occasionally calls himself stupid. Most of the kids in his neighborhood are older, and he’s one of the younger children in his kindergarten class. In

Read More »